Anyway, New Jersey’s favorite "style" Oreo is the Golden Oreo. But what is the Garden State’s favorite Oreo flavor? It was the favorite in six other states including our neighbors New York and Pennsylvania. It could be associated with a song we were supposed to sing twice when washing hands during the pandemic.

However, we have to admit that Oreo is off to a pretty great start in 2025, too. Earlier this year, the beloved cookie brand practically broke the internet with the release of its Post Malone Oreos that featured a first-of-its-kind swirl of salted caramel- and shortbread-flavored cremes.

A retired Oreo flavor will return to shelves soon, along with a new permanent flavor. Oreo is bringing back its Golden Birthday Cake cookies on March 3, just in time to “celebrate Milk’s Favorite Cookie turning another year older,